Knowledge is Power/Literacy R.O.C.K.S.

I saw this in a new twitter followers blog and liked it very much. Sadly though the sentence can be read in a different light as well. You know, even though knowledge is power there are plenty of over-humans out there whom it appears have super knowledge because they apparently have their super-human heads stuck in books all day. Consequently, they come across as probably being the ones who use that stored-up knowledge as a weapon to bash up some under-humans whom they feel very strongly to be less brainy. Twitter, blogs and facebook are awash with examples of these condescending Übermensch. They have the knowledge so that means they get to have the power. They use language as a weapon to abuse people all the time.

Ophelia Benson has a good point via Dan Fincke on the subject here

 July 28, 2012 at 4:54 pm  Ophelia Benson

Dan Fincke has a good point in comments on his own post about namecalling on blogs (or on his blog, which comes to the same thing). It’s a point that I probably ought to do a better job of keeping in mind.

The post says don’t call people demeaning names, and says why. (It’s obvious why, of course, but having it spelled out is useful.)

Words like these use emotional violence to coerce people with the aim of driving them into submission. These words aim to do that by demeaning them so that they feel worthless and hated. These words aim to irrationally gain leverage in an argument by making someone feel intellectually insecure and interpersonally rejected if they do not concede the other person’s debating point. These words try to drive people away with hostility. And, finally, these words try to coerce moral agreement by making the implicit threat of stigmatization and ostracism of any who differ.

A commenter makes a distinction between kinds of namecalling.

Stupid, jerk and asshole though? These are NOT minority-bashing words that silence a marginalized group of people. They’re just offensive words (and even there, jerk and stupid are just mildly offensive, IMO).  Sometimes the actions and words of others deserve to be called out for being stupid.  Often, people act in certain ways that are indeed undesirable and they deserve the label of jerk.

Dan rejects the distinction.

Stupid is a serious word that torments more people than tranny does.

And no, it’s not about “playing nice”, it’s about having mature, civil discussions like adults, not like playground bullies.

“Stupid” is just not a word that smart people have ruining their self-esteem from the time they’re little kids.

And even yet, it is a false and belittling word that is counterproductive to constructive discourse. Calling someone stupid tempts them to either slink away in shame or to fight back with equal emotional abuse.

As I said – he has a point.

And another point.

I’m pretty sure, based on my knowledge of human psychology and what other less educated people have indicated to me, that when you belittle other people as stupid those who feel intellectually unequal to you are being made insecure and nervous that you would do the same thing to [them]. It’s bad enough they feel intimidated to begin with. It’s insensitive of you to carelessly use words that relate to their insecurity. They are likely to identify with whomever you’re denigrating and feel at least a twinge of anxiety over it. “Check your privilege” (as the kids like to say).

Yes – that is undeniably a point.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

The above-humans as in the above and over other humans have warped superiority complexes. They must not be knowledgeable enough though, to let it sink in that their own brain power is all in the head, and with the press of a button or the onset of sudden dementia of sorts such as alzheimers the brain power could be swiped away. So fragile is the mind and so small are those who think they’re super-human.

There were millions of people slaughtered and burned in gas-chambers because they were classed as inferior by some so called super-humans. So, one must never forget what superior minded people are capable of doing to vulnerable humans. For example, if they had ancestors who suffered because they were considered nonentities they should be the last people in the world to have high notions about themselves that causes them to look down on others because they feel they’re not as intelligent as themselves. They should be the last ones to keep implying on the Internet that they’re of a higher order and as a consequence therefore have the god-given right to further intimate and persecute perceived underlings.. Or, even to think that they are so uppity arrogant, snobbish, hoity-toity, snooty, pretentious, bumptious, full of oneself, puffed up, conceited, pompous, self-assertive, overbearing, cocky, cocksure, impertinent, haughty, self-important, superior, presumptuous, overweening, uppish, high and mighty; too big for one’s britches/boots that folk should have more time for them as they’re, well, doncha know, so educated and can express themselves via their writing, and sure…where would the blogosphere world be without their alluringly tantalizingly provocative, arousing, seductive, suggestive, inviting, titillating;   sensuous, slinky, coquettish, amorous, flirtatious; come-hither, decorous, come-read-me instantly super-human minds gracing the Internet. They are the Internet, god damn it. Not to be linked with the under-educated boring classes that drive their fans nuts. They’re the twitter chattering bohemians classes and there is nobody to compare with their wealth of meta Wikipedia type of knowledge. They’re the ones who are so privileged that they get to use words like illiterate or stupid as a form of irony or provocatively. They create inner circles, and anyone not considered intellectual enough is not wanted within these Über circles. The nouveau -riche intellectual elitists should remember their innings, as I’m sure it’s not that very long ago that that they came from very plain simple uneducated people with little or no literacy skills? See how intelligent they are – that they have to form inner circles in order to protect themselves from inferior untermenchen. Just saying…knowledge is power.

The comments are especially revealing and well worth reading.

See: A camel with a hammer offers a tap upside the head

kassad says:

Stupid IS hurtful. And saying “it is not as hurtful as tranny, nigger, cunt,…” was not Dan point, he in fact said exactly that in the comments.

I had a friend who was verbally abused by his parents. “Stupid” was pretty much how he defined himself since as long as he could remember. We talk for hours to him, especially in high school when he started to have even worse self-esteem. He killed himself at 17 years old.
My mother was dyslexic and dyscalculic (so am I) but it wasn’t until she was an adult. As a result, she always had a low self-esteem, amplified by the fact that she was adopted and her mother was an english teacher and her father was an engineer. She barely finished high school. My father is a naval engineer, one of the youngest Navy officer there was, graduated high school with 2 years in advance. He is smart and never had any issue about it. Despite his many qualities, he is not always the most insightful man and has difficulties really understanding my mother’s issues. He is intelligent, he loves her partly because she is intelligent too and they have a lot to talk about. Where is the problem right? This is why one of the more vivid memory of my youth was the look on my mother’s face when, in a banal discussion, my father said that what my mother’s argument was stupid. It was not aggressive, not a put down, at least that is not what my father intended at all. He probably forgot about it in minutes. But the recoil from my mother, the hurt on a her face stayed with me even if I did not understand it until years later.
This word “stupid” defined how my mother saw herself in the world how she envisioned her relationships, how she raised us. It took tremendous effort to surmount the hurt it did to her.

I am sorry if I run a little long and recited my life story, but the stories of my friend and my mother are not rare. And they are not “innocuous”.

I think that the phrase about “stupid hurting more people than tranny” was ill-advised, and understandably offensive to many people. But the whole “stupid is barely offensive, look at people being called cunts! Now that is suffering, not those hurt fee-fees from cry-babies that are simply called stupid” hit something in me. I feel like people dismissing this word are privileged not to have their intelligence (and thus their personal worth in some cases) questioned or taught that they never will have anything of value to contribute, ever.

Anyway, sorry for the long post.

Thank you Kassad for that poignant comment over at OB’s place. These innocuous people ought to spend a day in a literacy centre for adults who are proudly trying to pick up the pieces of  the times when they were put down by those who considered themselves superior. They would think twice about mocking people or using the Internet or twitter to continually hound people and slag them off because they do not have their credentials. They feign concern for people, but are just wolves in sheep clothing. Knowledge is power, so why don’t the powerful spend some time catering for those whom thy consider not as intelligent as themselves. They too could learn a thing or two from the uneducated classes.

Advertisements

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s